It looks like I won't sell Oracle for $22.50 this week (1 chance in 5). I plan to continue trying to write $22.50 call options on my shares because they continue to be fully-valued. I mentioned last month, that it is nice to have more than one reason to own a stock and the income from writing options is a good reason. Besides that, if the option is exercised, I feel I'm getting a fair price.
The big news for Oracle was their offer last week to buy BEA. I've learned a bit about how to evaluate mergers and I think the offer is pretty good, but is likely too be raised before all is said and done. If the premium offered is less than the expected value of the synergies produced, a transaction my be considered successful. In this case, the premium is at least $1.3 billion. Before the announcement, BEAS was priced at $13.62 a share and the offer price is $17—a premium of $3.38 a share times 392 million shares. Oracle hinted it considers the premium to be even higher: "Our proposed price is a substantial premium to an already-inflated stock price that reflected speculation of the potential sale of BEA and represents a more than 40% premium to BEA's stock price before the appearance of activist shareholders in mid-August of this year." Carl Icahn is, of course, the "activist shareholders" the letter refers to. I'm not going to factor that in, however, since the stock traded higher than $14 as recently as July 19 of this year and has been in the general range for most of the last twelve months.
Synergies are a bit harder to calculate. The market clearly thinks Oracle will need to raise its price since BEAS is trading at $18.55 a share (a $1.9 billion premium). An obvious source of synergy stems from Oracle's high operating margin (33%) compared to BEA's (14%). If Oracle simply trimmed BEA costs to match its own, it would earn an extra $205 million a year in synergies. Using an 11% cost of capital, that works out to about $1.9 billion. Further benefits, such as the ability to cross-sell products to BEA customers and technological improvements, are not included but are also less certain and harder to calculate. I'd assume they are a counter-balanced by integration costs, but they probably do exist.
I just read the chapter on Mergers and Acquisitions in Expectations Investing. One important concept it presents is Shareholder Value at Risk (SVAR), which quantifies how much of current shareholder's value the company is betting on an acquisition. For an all-cash offer, the math is pretty easy and works out to 1.2%. If the offer goes up to $18.55, as the market currently predicts, the SVAR is 1.7%. The highest offer I've seen speculated is $21 a share, which would risk 2.5% of shareholders current value. Any way you slice it, this offer will not have a huge impact on Oracle's long-term performance.
So to sum up, I like Oracle's prospects and the current offer to BEA, but I'm still trying to sell call options so that I can earn some extra income on this fairly-valued position. Got it?
